Reviewer Guidelines

  1. Please check if the article matches your area of expertise if you feel it does not match, please contact the editor soon.
  2. After login to the Open Journal System (OJS) of the Agribiba Journal, please accept the review request by click “will do” the review. If you find problem to Login to the OJS, please contact the administrator: Mrs. Rimelke Rahmadea Febryane, email: [email protected], phone/ SMS/ WA: +62-85714390438
  3. Please pay attention to the due date, which is the deadline of the review period. Please accomplish your review within the due date. The delay of your review decision slows down the review process, this causes waiting for author.
  4. After you accept the review request in the OJS, you will be able to download the manuscript in word type (.doc).
  5. Please treat the manuscript as a confidential document, do not share it to anyone else, except with the permission of Editor/s for reviewing purposes.
  6. Please use the Microsoft Word to comment on the manuscript using the “Review” tool.
  7. Provide feedback objectively, politely, and constructively, without personally offensive comments.
  8. Maintain the confidentiality of the content of the manuscript and do not use the information in it for personal gain.
  9. Do not review if there is a conflict of interest (e.g. personal/professional relationship with the author).
  10. Kindly check the following items:
  • Title and Abstract: Does the title reflect the content? Is the abstract concise and includes objectives, methods, results, and conclusions?
  • Originality: Is the topic or approach new and not widely discussed?
  • Relevance: Does the topic fit the focus and scope of the journal?
  • Methodology: Are the methods used appropriate and valid?
  • Data Analysis: Is the data analyzed correctly and in depth?
  • Results and Discussion: Is the discussion critical enough and linked to theory or previous research?
  • Conclusion: Does the conclusion answer the research objectives?
  • Reference: Is the literature relevant and up to date? Is the format appropriate?
  1. After you review, please login to the Open Journal System (OJS) of Agribiba Journal, complete the “Reviewer’s Comments” and upload the file with your comments. Finally, decide the status of the article please select one from the following option.
  • Accept Submission (without revision)
  • Revisions Required
  • Resubmit for Review
  • Resubmit Elsewhere
  • Decline Submission (Reject)
  • After selecting the option, kindly click the “Submit Review” button.